Law · Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Justice Thomas explains two Supreme Court denials, one on speech and one on guns
The File desk · Nov. 17, 2026, 6:18 a.m. ET
Confirmed3 primary sourcesAdded 6:18 a.m. ET, Nov. 17
Status
- ConfirmedThe order list deniesand
Legal instrument
Khatibi v. Yip
Supreme Court No. 25-1240. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to California's implicit-bias requirement for continuing medical education. Justice Gorsuch would have granted the petition. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented. The dissent says the Ninth Circuit treated credit-eligible course content as government speech.
, with a dissent and a statement from Justice Thomas, and deniesLegal instrument
Novotny v. Moore
Supreme Court No. 25-1324. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to Maryland limits on carrying firearms. Justice Thomas filed a statement respecting the denial. He agreed not to take the broad petition and wrote that a narrower case should consider states' authority to ban firearms in sensitive places.
with no noted dissent.Legal instrument
Trump v. Thakur
Supreme Court No. 26-210. The November 16, 2026 order list denies the petition with no explanation and no noted dissent. The docket names Donald J. Trump and others against Neeta Thakur and others, from the Ninth Circuit, and does not state the legal question.
- ConfirmedThe docket does not state whatis about. This story does not supply a subject the docket does not print.
Legal instrument
Trump v. Thakur
Supreme Court No. 26-210. The November 16, 2026 order list denies the petition with no explanation and no noted dissent. The docket names Donald J. Trump and others against Neeta Thakur and others, from the Ninth Circuit, and does not state the legal question.
Legal instrument
Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms
No. 25-1421 on the November 16, 2026 order list. The Court granted review, vacated the judgment, and sent the case back to the California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, for another look in light of Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II.
Legal instrument
Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II
The 2026 Supreme Court decision, 608 U. S. 219, that the order list cites as the reason for sending Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms back to the state court. This order does not describe what Montgomery held.
Legal instrument
Huffman v. United States
No. 26-5528 on the November 16, 2026 order list. The Court granted review, vacated the judgment, and sent the case back to the Fifth Circuit for another look in light of Hunter v. United States.
Legal instrument
Hunter v. United States
The 2026 Supreme Court decision, 608 U. S. 713, that the order list cites as the reason for sending Huffman v. United States back to the Fifth Circuit. This order does not describe what Hunter held.
Legal instrument
Khatibi v. Yip
Supreme Court No. 25-1240. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to California's implicit-bias requirement for continuing medical education. Justice Gorsuch would have granted the petition. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented. The dissent says the Ninth Circuit treated credit-eligible course content as government speech.
Legal instrument
First Amendment
The constitutional protection against the government interfering with speech. In the November 16, 2026 order, Justice Thomas writes that the Ninth Circuit held this scrutiny did not apply because it called the medical-course content government speech.
Legal instrument
First Amendment
The constitutional protection against the government interfering with speech. In the November 16, 2026 order, Justice Thomas writes that the Ninth Circuit held this scrutiny did not apply because it called the medical-course content government speech.
Legal instrument
Shurtleff v. Boston
The 2022 Supreme Court decision Justice Thomas says the Ninth Circuit used to decide what counts as government speech. His dissent says the test looks at the history of the expression, who the public thinks is speaking, and how far the government shaped the message. He writes that the Court should reconsider whether that test is the right one.
Legal instrument
Novotny v. Moore
Supreme Court No. 25-1324. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to Maryland limits on carrying firearms. Justice Thomas filed a statement respecting the denial. He agreed not to take the broad petition and wrote that a narrower case should consider states' authority to ban firearms in sensitive places.
Legal instrument
Second Amendment
The constitutional right to keep and bear arms. Justice Thomas's statement in Novotny v. Moore says the petition raised a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland's carry limits.
Legal instrument
New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn., Inc. v. Bruen
The 2022 Supreme Court decision cited in Justice Thomas's statement, reported at 597 U. S. 1. The statement quotes it for the rule that a firearm restriction must fit the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
Legal instrument
Khatibi v. Yip
Supreme Court No. 25-1240. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to California's implicit-bias requirement for continuing medical education. Justice Gorsuch would have granted the petition. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented. The dissent says the Ninth Circuit treated credit-eligible course content as government speech.
Legal instrument
Novotny v. Moore
Supreme Court No. 25-1324. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to Maryland limits on carrying firearms. Justice Thomas filed a statement respecting the denial. He agreed not to take the broad petition and wrote that a narrower case should consider states' authority to ban firearms in sensitive places.
Legal instrument
Trump v. Thakur
Supreme Court No. 26-210. The November 16, 2026 order list denies the petition with no explanation and no noted dissent. The docket names Donald J. Trump and others against Neeta Thakur and others, from the Ninth Circuit, and does not state the legal question.
How we know
Notes
- 1.Supreme Court of the United States, order list for Monday, November 16, 2026 (610 U.S.). Certiorari denied in , No. 25-1240, Ninth Circuit, with Justice Gorsuch recorded as would grant, and Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissenting. Certiorari denied in
Legal instrument
Khatibi v. Yip
Supreme Court No. 25-1240. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to California's implicit-bias requirement for continuing medical education. Justice Gorsuch would have granted the petition. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented. The dissent says the Ninth Circuit treated credit-eligible course content as government speech.
, No. 25-1324, Fourth Circuit, with a statement by Justice Thomas respecting the denial. Certiorari denied inLegal instrument
Novotny v. Moore
Supreme Court No. 25-1324. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to Maryland limits on carrying firearms. Justice Thomas filed a statement respecting the denial. He agreed not to take the broad petition and wrote that a narrower case should consider states' authority to ban firearms in sensitive places.
, No. 26-210, with no reasons and no noted dissent. Summary dispositions:Legal instrument
Trump v. Thakur
Supreme Court No. 26-210. The November 16, 2026 order list denies the petition with no explanation and no noted dissent. The docket names Donald J. Trump and others against Neeta Thakur and others, from the Ninth Circuit, and does not state the legal question.
, No. 25-1421, granted, vacated, and remanded to the Court of Appeal of California, Fifth Appellate District, in light ofLegal instrument
Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms
No. 25-1421 on the November 16, 2026 order list. The Court granted review, vacated the judgment, and sent the case back to the California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, for another look in light of Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II.
, LLC, 608 U. S. 219 (2026);Legal instrument
Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II
The 2026 Supreme Court decision, 608 U. S. 219, that the order list cites as the reason for sending Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms back to the state court. This order does not describe what Montgomery held.
, No. 26-5528, granted, vacated, and remanded to the Fifth Circuit in light ofLegal instrument
Huffman v. United States
No. 26-5528 on the November 16, 2026 order list. The Court granted review, vacated the judgment, and sent the case back to the Fifth Circuit for another look in light of Hunter v. United States.
, 608 U. S. 713 (2026). Retrieved by this desk Nov. 17. Confirmed. Source 1. https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/111626zor_cb7d.pdfLegal instrument
Hunter v. United States
The 2026 Supreme Court decision, 608 U. S. 713, that the order list cites as the reason for sending Huffman v. United States back to the Fifth Circuit. This order does not describe what Hunter held.
- 2.Supreme Court of the United States, Visitor's Guide to Oral Argument. The guide says a case selected for argument is one that at least four Justices have selected. The Court's page on its procedures says the justices each week evaluate approximately 130 petitions seeking review, to decide which cases are granted full review. The order list itself does not print a vote count. Retrieved by this desk Nov. 17. Confirmed. Source 2. https://www.supremecourt.gov/visiting/visitorsguidetooralargument.aspx
- 3.Supreme Court of the United States, docket for No. 26-210, . Docketed August 19, 2026. Lower court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 25-4249, decision date May 26, 2026. November 16, 2026: Petition DENIED. Counsel of record for the petitioners: D. John Sauer, Solicitor General. Counsel of record for the respondents: Erwin Chemerinsky. The docket title names the parties and does not state the legal question. Retrieved by this desk Nov. 17. Confirmed. Source 3. https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-210.html
Legal instrument
Trump v. Thakur
Supreme Court No. 26-210. The November 16, 2026 order list denies the petition with no explanation and no noted dissent. The docket names Donald J. Trump and others against Neeta Thakur and others, from the Ninth Circuit, and does not state the legal question.
What is still unknown or disputed
- The legal question in . It is not on the order list or the docket.
Legal instrument
Trump v. Thakur
Supreme Court No. 26-210. The November 16, 2026 order list denies the petition with no explanation and no noted dissent. The docket names Donald J. Trump and others against Neeta Thakur and others, from the Ninth Circuit, and does not state the legal question.
- How many justices voted to deny. The list does not print a tally. It does say Justice Gorsuch would grant in , and that Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented there.
Legal instrument
Khatibi v. Yip
Supreme Court No. 25-1240. On November 16, 2026, the Court denied review of a challenge to California's implicit-bias requirement for continuing medical education. Justice Gorsuch would have granted the petition. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented. The dissent says the Ninth Circuit treated credit-eligible course content as government speech.
- Whether a narrower petition will be filed. The orders do not say.
Primary sources
Every claim in this story is drawn from the documents below. If a fetch failed, that is recorded on the card.
Source 1
Order list, Monday, November 16, 2026
Supreme Court of the United States · November 16, 2026
The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. JUSTICE GORSUCH would grant the petition for a writ of certiorari. JUSTICE THOMAS, with whom JUSTICE ALITO joins, dissenting from the denial of certiorari.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/111626zor_cb7d.pdf
Source 2
Visitor's Guide to Oral Argument
Supreme Court of the United States · November 17, 2026
At least four Justices have selected the case as being of such importance that the Supreme Court must resolve the legal issues.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/visiting/visitorsguidetooralargument.aspx
Source 3
Docket for No. 26-210
Supreme Court of the United States · November 16, 2026
Donald J. Trump, President of the United States, et al., Petitioners v. Neeta Thakur, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, et al. Nov 16 2026 Petition DENIED.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-210.html