Every claim traces to a primary source. Uncertainty is labeled. Corrections are public.
Law · Monday, November 16, 2026
Appeals court sets aside New York highway-aid penalty over a missing rule
The File desk · Nov. 16, 2026, 6:24 a.m. ET
Confirmed1 primary sourcesAdded 6:24 a.m. ET, Nov. 16
Status
Confirmed. The holding, the dollar figures, the panel, and the concurrence are in the Second Circuit's opinion in
Legal instrument
State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation, No. 26-1097
New York asked the Second Circuit to review a final decision of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. On November 13, 2026, the court granted that petition and set the decision aside. A petition for review is a request that an appeals court examine an agency's final decision directly.
, decided Friday, November 13, 2026, which this desk opened.
Confirmed
The court granted New York's petition and set aside FMCSA's final determination. The opinion states the $73,502,543 withholding and the possible later amount of $147,005,086.
Confirmed
Judge Schwartz concurred in the judgment only. The opinion does not say whether the government will seek further review, or when New York receives the money.
On Friday, November 13, 2026, a federal appeals court set aside a federal agency's decision to hold back $73,502,543 in highway aid from New York.1 The government had penalized the State for breaking a rule. The court's answer was that the rule did not exist.1
The case went straight to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. New York filed a petition for review, which asks an appeals court to examine an agency's final decision directly, rather than starting in a trial court.1 The opinion says this court has "exclusive jurisdiction" to "set aside . . . all rules, regulations, or final orders of the Secretary of Transportation."1 The case is
Legal instrument
State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation, No. 26-1097
New York asked the Second Circuit to review a final decision of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. On November 13, 2026, the court granted that petition and set the decision aside. A petition for review is a request that an appeals court examine an agency's final decision directly.
, State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation.1
The fight was over commercial driver's licenses issued to people who are not domiciled in the United States.1 New York issued these non-domiciled licenses to foreign citizens living in the United States, "such as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival (DACA) recipients, asylees, and refugees," who showed they were lawfully present when they applied.1 The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration said New York had not matched those licenses' expiration dates to the dates on the drivers' lawful-presence papers. It found the State not substantially compliant and withheld four percent of New York's federal highway aid for fiscal year 2027.1 By the opinion's account, the initial withholding "amounted to $73,502,543 and subsequent withholdings could reach $147,005,086."1
Here is how the penalty works. The
Legal instrument
Commercial Motor Vehicle Safety Act
This statute governs state issuance of licenses for trucks, buses, and similar vehicles in interstate commerce. It lets the Secretary of Transportation set minimum standards and withhold federal highway aid if a state does not comply substantially. The Second Circuit's opinion in No. 26-1097 describes that authority.
lets the Secretary withhold highway aid when a state does not comply substantially with the commercial-license rules.1 So the question came down to what those rules said. In the period this case covers, the rule told a state to make a commercial driver's license valid for no more than eight years. The court said it did not require the expiration dates to match.1
Notice who agrees. "As FMCSA itself concedes, the plain text of the federal regulations in place during the relevant period did not contain an expiration-matching requirement."1 From there the conclusion follows. The court wrote that "the agency could not withhold federal funding based on a state's noncompliance with a regulatory requirement that did not exist."1
The court held the final determination arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law, granted the petition, and set the determination aside.1 The phrase comes from the statute the opinion cites, which tells a court to "hold unlawful and set aside agency action, findings, and conclusions found to be arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law."1
Judge Nathan wrote the opinion, for a panel of Judges Nathan, Merriam, and Schwartz. The case was argued on September 28, 2026.1 Judge Schwartz concurs in the judgment only, in a separate opinion.1 That means he agrees with the result and not with every step of the majority's reasons. He writes that the majority should have stopped at the plain text, and he objects to its discussion of regulatory structure and history.1
But notice what the court did not decide. A later rule added an explicit matching requirement. The court decided only the earlier period.1
Why it matters (Estimate).Estimate. The ruling lifts the agency's finding that New York was out of compliance, and that finding was the basis for holding back the highway aid. What comes next is not in the opinion. It does not say when the money is paid, or whether the government will ask for a rehearing or for Supreme Court review. The ruling covers only the older rule; the later matching requirement was not before the court. This is our reading of the opinion.
The rule in force set an eight-year limit on a license. It said nothing about matching dates, and the agency conceded as much — and that is where things stand.
How we know
Notes
1.U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit,
Legal instrument
State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation, No. 26-1097
New York asked the Second Circuit to review a final decision of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. On November 13, 2026, the court granted that petition and set the decision aside. A petition for review is a request that an appeals court examine an agency's final decision directly.
, State of New York et al. v. U.S. Department of Transportation et al., argued September 28, 2026, decided November 13, 2026. Opinion by Judge Nathan. Judge Schwartz concurred in the judgment only. As of July 2025, about 32,600 non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses and learner's permits were outstanding in New York, about seven percent of the total. New York issued them for five years at first issuance and eight years on renewal. FMCSA sampled 200 and found 101 still valid after the holder's lawful-presence document expired. An interim final rule on September 29, 2025, added an explicit expiration-matching requirement and was stayed by the D.C. Circuit. A February 2026 final rule took effect March 16, 2026. The D.C. Circuit refused to stay that final rule in May 2026. The Second Circuit decided only the earlier period. Retrieved by this desk Nov. 16. Confirmed. Source 1. https://ww3.ca2.uscourts.gov/decisions/OPN/26-1097_complete_opn.pdf
What is still unknown or disputed
Whether the government will seek rehearing or Supreme Court review. The opinion does not mention such a filing.
When New York receives the money. The opinion does not say.
Primary sources
Every claim in this story is drawn from the documents below. If a fetch failed, that is recorded on the card.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · November 13, 2026
As FMCSA itself concedes, the plain text of the federal regulations in place during the relevant period did not contain an expiration-matching requirement. We therefore GRANT New York's petition and set aside FMCSA's final determination.